View this post on Instagram

A post shared by Soccer Laduma (@soccer_laduma)

Login

Truter: Stats Don't Back Mbuthuma To Chiefs Or Pirates

Truter: Stats Don't Back Mbuthuma To Chiefs Or Pirates

Inacio Miguel of Kaizer Chiefs challenged by Yanela Mbuthuma of Richards Bay during the Betway Premiership 2024/25 match between Richards Bay and Kaizer Chiefs at the King Zwelithini Stadium, Umlazi on the 16 March 2025

Yanela Mbuthuma's recent performances have put him firmly on the radar of some of the PSL's big guns, with both Orlando Pirates and Kaizer Chiefs understood to be interested in acquiring his services.

The Richards Bay FC forward's display against Chiefs in his team's 2-0 victory has only added to the growing speculation about his future in the Betway Premiership.

Read – New Chapter After Chiefs: Ramushu's Contract Details Revealed 

Former Richards Bay coach Brandon Truter, who has worked closely with Mbuthuma, has provided insight into the young striker's capabilities and potential.

Truter acknowledges Mbuthuma as a talented player with the right attributes to succeed at a high level.

He recalls how he frequently challenged the forward in training, pushing him to refine his skills and improve his overall game.

However, despite his promising abilities, Truter points out that statistics do not favour the young striker.

In a footballing landscape where strikers are primarily judged by their goal-scoring records, Mbuthuma has yet to establish himself among the elite.

Truter emphasises that for a player to be mentioned alongside the likes of the late Lesley Manyathela, Collins Mbesuma, and Peter Shalulile, he must have the numbers to back up his talent.

While Mbuthuma shows flashes of brilliance, his goalscoring record does not yet place him in that category.

The coach also raises concerns about the striker's appeal to European clubs, noting that in the modern game, top clubs look at performance data before making recruitment decisions. Without a strong statistical backing, it would be difficult for Mbuthuma to secure a move overseas at this stage of his career, according to Truter.

With interest from domestic giants, the next step for Mbuthuma will be crucial. If he can sharpen his finishing and add consistency to his performances, he has the potential to become a top-tier striker in South African football.

"Yeah, Mbuthuma, I know him very well. He is a player that I've challenged a lot at training. He is a player that possesses a lot of attributes to be a top striker. In a right environment, he will flourish," said Truter, speaking exclusively to the Siya crew.

Read – How Riveiro's Future Could Change Saleng's Decision 

"But he is also a player that stats don't back him. When you are a striker, you get judged on goals, and that's where it points to. With young players, it's about doing more – getting on that level where you can talk about Lesley Manyathela, Collins Mbesuma, Peter Shalulile and these guys – and all these guys have goals to back them up. With those guys, whatever you need to talk about, whether it's bad or good, and they point to their goals, you can't argue with that - they are strikers. It depends on what type of striker you need and that moment, and that's how I look at it. Do we want to develop a complete striker that can compete? At this moment, if a European team is coming for Yanela and looks at his stats, there will be no chance that he will leave our shores," said the coach.

Get ready for a football spectacle like no other as the SportPesa Cup2025 takes centre stage from Friday 21 March to Sunday 23 March, at Edgemead Football Club.

Related tags

Comments

Top 5

Al Ahly 'Confirm' Riveiro Decision After CWC Loss

Jun 21, 2025 10:25 AM in African Football

Guardiola Lauds Rulani Signing At Wydad

Jun 20, 2025 01:19 PM in International

Moremi Confirmed – Seven More Signings Expected At Pirates

Jun 22, 2025 04:00 PM in Orlando-Pirates

Chiefs-Linked Attacker Lands 'New Deal'

Jun 22, 2025 12:26 PM in African Football

Sundowns Players Who Could Leave Despite CWC Inclusion

Jun 19, 2025 08:27 AM in Mamelodi-Sundowns

One More Hurdle For Chiefs To Sign Okon?

Jun 23, 2025 01:51 PM in Kaizer-Chiefs

Mokwana Attracts 'Interest' From European Sides At CWC

Jun 23, 2025 11:24 AM in African Football

War Tension Threatens Possibility Of Mofokeng To Israel

Jun 23, 2025 11:41 AM in Orlando-Pirates

Zamalek 'Given' Three Conditions To Sign Tau

Jun 23, 2025 12:18 PM in African Football

Amakhosi Star Marries Long-Time Love

Jun 23, 2025 01:10 PM in Fan Park