Register Login Live

SL Gaming

Dutch Court Gives Landmark Ruling In FIFA 22 Gambling Controversy

A Dutch court has made a ruling on the controversial FIFA Ultimate Team packs and as to whether or not it amounts to gambling.

Ultimate Team packs have been surrounded by controversy, and court cases, for some time now, with many feeling that purchasing the packs is a form of gambling.

Read: eFootball Back In The Fight After Latest Update

This is because you are not certain of the players that will be in each pack, and could end up spending more and more in the hope of getting the player card that you want.

However, in a landmark case in Holland, the court determined that Ultimate Team packs were not considered gambling.

GiveMeSport, quoting GamesIndustry, revealed that the Administrative Jurisdiction Division of the Dutch State Council ruled that FIFA packs were essentially not a game of chance.

One of the main reasons for their decision is that the packs in FIFA are considered an "inseparable part" of the game, and with the court being the highest administrative court in Holland, the decision is final.

The ruling was covered over nine pages, with the aim being to determine whether the FIFA Packs amounted to being a game of chance. Although not illegal in Holland, a permit from the Dutch Gambling Authority would be required.

The documentation outlined that a game of chance is considered by specific criteria, namely: A participant should have an opportunity to win prizes and the winner of the game is determined by chance.

The judge had to consider whether the 'loot boxes' could be considered a standalone game, which would then be assessed as a potential game of chance.

The report on GiveMeSport stated, "In terms of Ultimate Team, the judge has ruled that it is a game of skill, although a mixed one, because the games played within the mode are won by the best player.

Read: Dev: God Of War Sequel Coming This Year

"The judge also rules that the packs are considered part of this mode, rather than a standalone game, because the packs are acquired and opened within Ultimate Team."

Although a landmark ruling for FIFA, it is an interesting take on loot boxes overall, and could open the door to more cases where loot boxes are used for trading purposes.

Sonic Making Another Major Comeback

More Major Changes As New GT7 Update Drops

Pavendren Grabs SLL Crown In Grand Final

comments

Top 5

Downs Up The Ante In Nodada Pursuit?

89 Jul 04, 2022 09:01 AM in Mamelodi Sundowns

The Four Clubs CR7 Wants To Join Revealed?

1 Jul 05, 2022 08:28 AM in Messi/Ronaldo/Neymar/Mbappe Watch

Teen Sensation Training With Chiefs?

21 Jul 04, 2022 01:54 PM in Kaizer Chiefs

Arsenal's 10 Highest-Paid Players After Jesus Signing

Jul 04, 2022 09:24 PM in English Premier League

WATCH: Inside Sundowns' Pre-Season Medicals

17 Jul 04, 2022 11:55 AM in Mamelodi Sundowns

Official: Chiefs Confirm Another First-Team Departure

49 Jul 02, 2022 07:44 PM in Kaizer Chiefs

Axed Chiefs Star Makes Big Zwane Claim

56 Jul 02, 2022 03:01 PM in Kaizer Chiefs

First Look Inside 'New' Pirates Pre-Season Preparations

9 Jul 01, 2022 08:00 PM in Orlando Pirates

Downs To Announce Good News On Zwane!

29 Jul 04, 2022 10:55 AM in Mamelodi Sundowns

Mane Breaks Silence On Liverpool Exit

7 Jun 22, 2022 09:29 AM in Bundesliga News

Report: Lukaku's Chelsea Exit Confirmed

Jun 22, 2022 08:25 AM in English Premier League

Decision To Be Made On Mmodi?

7 Jul 04, 2022 10:01 AM in Siyagobhoza