Register Login Scores

Fan Park

Whose CAF Final XI Was Better – Sundowns' Or Pirates'?

Mamelodi Sundowns are the second South African team in the space of a year to participate in a final of a CAF competition, but who had the better squad – Downs or Orlando Pirates?

The Brazilians secured a 3-0 result in the first leg of the CAF Champions League final against Zamalek, and, today, they will be leaving for Egypt to face the White Knights in the reverse fixture.

Despite not having Leonardo Castro and new signings Anele Ngcongca and Sibusiso Vilakazi in the team, Pitso Mosimane's men came out strong in the first leg.

Twelve months ago, a different story unfolded, however. Eric Tinkler's Bucs side were in the final of the CAF Confederations Cup against Etoile du Sahel, and a 1-1 draw was recorded at Orlando Stadium. 

Both line-ups are taken from the first-leg fixtures at each PSL club's home ground, but who had the better squad?

Here is a look at the two teams:

Mamelodi Sundowns XI vs Zamalek (3-0): Onyango, Langerman, Nthethe, Arendse (Soumahoro 70'), Mbekile, Kekana (T Zwane 86'), Mabunda, Billiat (Modise 65'), Tau, Dolly, Laffor

Orlando Pirates XI vs Etoile du Sahel (1-1): Ovono, Sangweni, Jele, Gcaba, Matlaba, Masalesa (Sarr 83'), Ntshumayelo, Makola, Rakhale, Gabuza, Erasmus (Motupa 88') 

Which team, for you, had the better line-up?

94 comments

Top 5

Breaking: Chiefs Suspend Bobby!

83 Aug 04, 2020 04:09 PM in Kaizer Chiefs

11 South African-born Players Who Represented Other Countries

24 Jul 11, 2020 08:01 PM in African Football

10 Footballers Who Were Rich Before Football

9 Jul 24, 2020 07:16 PM in International

Bobby’s Suspension: ‘This Is A Family Issue’

65 Aug 04, 2020 07:18 PM in Kaizer Chiefs

Rakhale's Best Looks Alongside His Car Collection

Aug 05, 2020 10:59 AM in Drip, Style & Swag

Drogba Causes Stir In Ivory Coast

18 Aug 03, 2020 05:02 PM in International

Solskjaer Confirms High-Profile Man Utd Departure

1 Aug 06, 2020 12:09 AM in Manchester United

Man Utd Unveil 2020/21 Home Kit

8 Aug 04, 2020 05:21 PM in Manchester United

Breaking: Chiefs Suspend Bobby!

83 Aug 04, 2020 04:09 PM in Kaizer Chiefs

Kekana: We Won’t Cope Without The Fans

28 Aug 04, 2020 08:41 AM in Mamelodi Sundowns

11 Footballers Who Went Broke

33 Jun 10, 2020 07:15 PM in World News

‘Pirates Played Good Football When He Was Here’

6 Aug 04, 2020 02:10 PM in Orlando Pirates

The 10 Richest Footballers In The World

11 May 20, 2020 08:32 PM in Messi/Ronaldo/Neymar Watch